As artificial intelligence continues to evolve, voice assistants have become smarter and more capable. Apple’s latest Apple Intelligence, running on the iPhone 15 with iOS 18.1 beta, is being compared to Google Gemini Advance on the Pixel 8. In this article, we put both AI assistants to the test by asking them the same 50 commands and analyzing their responses.
This comparison will help determine how each assistant performs, their response speed, accuracy, and overall capabilities. It’s important to note that both AI systems are still developing, with Apple Intelligence being introduced just last month. Many features are yet to roll out, so this test represents a snapshot in their current state.
Comparing AI Assistants on Key Features
1. Image Generation
Command: Generate a picture of a horse in the middle of a mountain.
- Google Gemini successfully generated an AI-created image from scratch.
- Apple Intelligence only retrieved existing images from the web.
- Upcoming Feature: Apple has teased a new tool called Image Playground, expected to launch soon.
2. Comparing Smartphones
Command: Compare the Galaxy S24 Ultra against the iPhone 15 Pro Max.
- Google Gemini provided a detailed side-by-side comparison.
- Apple Intelligence redirected to a web search rather than giving a direct comparison.
3. Understanding Self-Corrections
Command: Set a timer for 20 minutes… I mean 10 minutes… I mean 8 minutes.
- Apple Intelligence accurately followed the corrections in real time.
- Google Gemini struggled, only catching the first mistake but failing to adjust for the last correction.
4. Handling Multiple Commands
Command: What’s the weather in my area? Also, what time is it in Alaska? And who is the tallest man on Earth?
- Google Gemini successfully answered all three queries simultaneously.
- Apple Intelligence could not handle multiple commands at once and required separate inputs.
5. Recipe Suggestions Based on Available Ingredients
Command: I have yogurt, eggs, tomatoes, chicken, and strawberries. Create a recipe with these ingredients.
- Google Gemini generated a structured recipe suggestion.
- Apple Intelligence performed a Google search rather than generating a direct response.
6. Follow-Up Conversations
Commands:
- What is the capital of Argentina?
- What time is it there?
- Plan me a two-week trip there.
- Google Gemini provided a complete travel plan including flights, accommodations, and sightseeing recommendations.
- Apple Intelligence responded more quickly but required multiple prompts to proceed with the conversation.
7. Music and Song Recognition
Command: What song is playing in the background?
- Apple Intelligence used Shazam to identify the song.
- Google Gemini utilized Google Assistant’s music recognition feature.
- Both AI assistants accurately identified the song.
8. Reminder and Task Management
Commands:
- Remind me two weeks before my brother’s birthday to get him a gift.
- Give me gift ideas for my brother.
- Create a gift list for David and add a gaming mouse.
- Google Gemini handled all tasks efficiently and kept track of follow-ups.
- Apple Intelligence also managed reminders and lists but required extra confirmations.
9. Tech Support and Phone Management
Commands:
- What was my WiFi password again?
- How do you change the wallpaper on this phone?
- Show me some cool wallpapers.
- Help me save battery on my phone.
- Turn off Bluetooth.
- Download Angry Birds 2.
- Google Gemini provided step-by-step solutions.
- Apple Intelligence redirected to support articles for most queries.
10. Homework and Research Assistance
Commands:
- Solve: x + 3 = -9.
- Write me an essay on the current state of the economy.
- Find online sources for a research paper about algorithm analysis.
- Google Gemini provided direct answers and sources.
- Apple Intelligence mostly redirected to Safari search results.
11. Summarization and App Integration
- Apple Intelligence includes a Summarization Button in Safari, Mail, and Messages.
- Google Gemini integrates with Android apps, allowing users to attach links, screenshots, and videos.
12. Everyday Questions and Assistance
Commands tested:
- How much time did I spend on my phone today?
- What does my schedule look like?
- Save my parking location and remember that I parked next to a mailbox.
- Roll a 20-sided dice.
- What movies are playing in theaters now?
- What’s a 15% tip on a $43 meal?
- Google Gemini gave detailed responses.
- Apple Intelligence handled basic questions well but struggled with multi-step queries.
13. Fun and Entertainment
Commands:
- Rap for me.
- Tell me a dad joke.
- Surprise me with a fun fact.
- Who’s the best AI assistant?
- Google Gemini responded with more engaging and creative answers.
- Apple Intelligence kept responses straightforward and factual.
Final Verdict: Which AI Assistant is Better?
Strengths of Google Gemini:
- More detailed responses
- Better handling of multi-step commands
- Stronger summarization and app integration
- More engaging and creative replies
Strengths of Apple Intelligence:
- Faster response time
- Better at handling user mistakes and interruptions
- Smooth conversation flow
As of now, Google Gemini offers a more versatile and intelligent AI assistant experience, handling complex queries better. However, Apple Intelligence excels in quick, seamless interactions and is expected to improve significantly as Apple rolls out more features.
Both assistants are evolving, and in a few months, we may see a much closer competition. Keep an eye out for updates as AI technology continues to advance!
Tags:
AI assistant comparison, Apple Intelligence, Google Gemini, Siri vs Gemini, AI voice assistant, iPhone vs Android, AI performance test, best AI assistant, AI-generated images, smart assistants
Hashtags:
#AIComparison #AppleIntelligence #GoogleGemini #AIAssistant #SiriVsGemini #SmartAssistants #VoiceAI #AItechnology #BestAIAssistant #TechComparison
