Sometimes, a game doesn’t make sense the moment you start it. You play for a few minutes, get confused, even frustrated, and think: “Why did I buy this?”
Yet, a few hours later, it clicks. The design philosophy becomes clear. You find yourself smiling — not because the game suddenly became easy, but because it dared to be different.
These are the kinds of titles that divide players, earn love and hate in equal measure, and challenge expectations. They’re not perfect — in fact, they often feel broken or strange — but beneath that surface lies genius.
So, let’s take a closer look at 10 controversial games that might feel like a mistake at first, but eventually reveal their brilliance.
🪜 1. Baby Steps — The Most Polarizing Game of the Year
Let’s start with one of the strangest releases of 2025: Baby Steps, developed by Gabe Cuzzillo and Bennett Foddy — the mind behind Getting Over It.
At first glance, it looks like an odd walking simulator where a man in pajamas stumbles across mountains while delivering philosophical quips. Some players found it utterly pointless. Others called it their Game of the Year.
What makes it controversial is its deliberate awkwardness. Every step requires thought. You’ll fall, fail, and curse your controller, only to realize the frustration is the point.
Baby Steps is not meant to be smooth. It’s about patience, persistence, and absurdity — a physics-based joke wrapped inside a meditation on failure. Some call it art; others call it trolling. But once you embrace its rhythm, it becomes strangely therapeutic.
Why it feels like a mistake: You can barely walk straight for 10 minutes.
Why it turns brilliant: You realize mastery comes not from control, but acceptance.
🧩 2. Blue Prince — The Puzzle Game That Fights Back
Next on the list is Blue Prince, one of the highest-rated puzzle roguelikes of 2025 — and also one of the most divisive.
At first, it looks simple: rearrange rooms to create the perfect architectural path. But hidden underneath is a punishing roguelike system that randomizes your progress.
Some players adored its replayability and tense logic; others found it maddeningly unfair. Imagine spending an hour solving a puzzle, only for RNG to ruin your next run.
Still, when everything aligns, Blue Prince offers unmatched satisfaction — the joy of conquering a design that feels alive.
Why it feels like a mistake: The roguelike randomness destroys your hard-earned progress.
Why it turns brilliant: It forces you to think flexibly, not perfectly.
🕸️ 3. Silksong — The Sequel That Shocked Its Own Fans
When Team Cherry finally released Hollow Knight: Silksong, fans expected a worthy sequel to the beloved 2017 masterpiece. What they got instead was a brutal, almost punishing challenge that divided the entire community.
Silksong is stunning — visually and mechanically. But it’s not friendly. Fights that would have been optional bosses in the original are now mandatory. Combat is faster, enemies are crueler, and the stakes are higher.
Many players quit early, calling it too hard or exhausting. But for those who stuck with it, Silksong offered the purest sense of growth in years — every defeat taught something new.
Why it feels like a mistake: You thought it would be another relaxed Metroidvania.
Why it turns brilliant: It redefines what mastery and persistence mean in a platformer.
🧵 4. Penny’s Big Breakaway — When Sonic Fans Got a Surprise
After the success of Sonic Mania, everyone expected Sonic Mania 2. Instead, we got Penny’s Big Breakaway — a strange yet delightful momentum-based platformer that completely broke expectations.
In this game, movement is everything. You use Penny’s yo-yo to swing, dash, and ricochet through colorful worlds. But it’s not as simple as jumping and running — the physics demand precision and rhythm.
The first hour feels chaotic. You’ll fail jumps, mis-time swings, and question the controls. But once it clicks, Penny’s Big Breakaway feels like a speedrunner’s dream — every move flows into the next like choreography.
Why it feels like a mistake: It’s not Sonic. The movement feels awkward at first.
Why it turns brilliant: When mastered, it’s one of the most satisfying platformers ever made.
🦶 5. Anger Foot — Chaos, Comedy, and Pain
If you’ve ever wanted to kick everything that moves, Anger Foot is your fantasy come true. It’s a neon-colored first-person brawler that looks like a meme but plays like Hotline Miami on steroids.
At first, it seems like dumb fun — kick down doors, blast gangsters, move fast. But soon you realize it’s actually hard. Levels are long, checkpoints are few, and one mistake means restarting.
It’s brutal, ridiculous, and oddly cathartic. Each failed attempt teaches better rhythm and reflex. The chaos is part of the design — and when you finally clear a stage flawlessly, it feels euphoric.
Why it feels like a mistake: Dying hundreds of times for a single checkpoint.
Why it turns brilliant: Every restart hones your instincts — turning frustration into flow.
🎖️ 6. Spec Ops: The Line — A Shooter That Destroys Its Own Genre
Sometimes, controversy doesn’t come from difficulty — it comes from philosophy.
Spec Ops: The Line starts like a generic military shooter. Sand, soldiers, and slow-motion gunfights. But halfway through, the game turns on you. It questions why you’re playing, why you follow orders, and whether you’re the hero or the villain.
It’s not perfect — the gameplay feels dated and repetitive — but its storytelling is powerful. The final act leaves you unsettled, forcing introspection instead of celebration.
Many players hated it for being uncomfortable. Others hailed it as a masterpiece in narrative design.
Why it feels like a mistake: The combat is dull and repetitive.
Why it turns brilliant: It’s not about victory — it’s about confronting guilt.
👉 Note: The game has been delisted from most digital stores, so you may need to find a physical copy if you wish to play it.
🩸 7. Vampyr — The Moral Dilemma Simulator
Made by Dontnod Entertainment (the studio behind Life is Strange), Vampyr is a game that constantly tempts you.
You play as a doctor turned vampire in post-WWI London — forced to balance morality and hunger. Feed on civilians to grow stronger, or resist and risk weakness.
It’s slow, dialogue-heavy, and sometimes clunky. The combat isn’t flashy, and the world feels claustrophobic. But the choices matter. Every victim changes the city’s ecosystem, pushing entire districts into chaos or recovery.
It’s less about action, more about consequence.
Why it feels like a mistake: The pacing is slow, and combat feels unpolished.
Why it turns brilliant: It’s one of the few games that truly makes morality a gameplay mechanic.
👉 Official site: https://www.dont-nod.com/en/games/vampyr/
🔥 8. Pyre — The Strange Masterpiece by Supergiant Games
Supergiant is known for hits like Hades, Bastion, and Transistor. But Pyre, their 2017 title, remains their most divisive.
It looks like an RPG, feels like a visual novel, and plays like a fantasy sports game. Yes — instead of turn-based combat, you compete in magical three-on-three matches called Rites.
Some fans fell in love with its storytelling and world-building; others bounced off immediately, saying “this isn’t what I expected.”
But if you give it time, Pyre reveals a level of emotional depth unmatched in gaming. Win or lose, the story continues, reflecting your choices — and your failures — in poetic ways.
Why it feels like a mistake: The core gameplay (fantasy basketball) isn’t for everyone.
Why it turns brilliant: The fusion of narrative and mechanics is pure Supergiant magic.
👉 Official site: https://www.supergiantgames.com/games/pyre/
🧱 9. Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts — The Wrong Name for the Right Idea
When Rare released Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts, fans were furious. They expected a traditional platformer; instead, they got a sandbox vehicle-building game.
And honestly? It wasn’t what anyone asked for — but it was brilliant.
Players could craft vehicles from hundreds of parts to solve creative challenges. It was physics-driven, experimental, and imaginative — years ahead of its time. If it hadn’t carried the Banjo name, it might have been praised like Tears of the Kingdom for its freedom.
Why it feels like a mistake: It’s not a real Banjo-Kazooie sequel.
Why it turns brilliant: It pioneered the open-ended creativity we celebrate in modern games.
👹 10. Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne HD Remaster — The JRPG That Tests Your Limits
Lastly, we have Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne HD Remaster — a game that defines the phrase “brutally fair.”
It’s a haunting post-apocalyptic RPG where every decision matters and every fight can crush you. Newcomers from Persona were shocked by its difficulty — no social links, no mercy, just raw survival.
The infamous Matador Boss Fight has ended countless playthroughs. But mastering its turn-based combat feels like cracking a code — punishing but deeply rewarding.
It’s a test of patience and understanding, a philosophical journey disguised as a battle system.
Why it feels like a mistake: Unforgiving mechanics, cryptic systems, minimal guidance.
Why it turns brilliant: It rewards intelligence, resilience, and respect for strategy.
👉 Official site: https://www.atlus.com/smt3/
💬 Frequently Asked Questions
Q1. Why do some people love games that others hate?
Because innovation divides people. Games that experiment — with difficulty, storytelling, or mechanics — naturally polarize audiences.
Q2. Are “risky” games worth buying at full price?
Yes, if you value originality. These titles often provide experiences you can’t get anywhere else, even if they demand patience.
Q3. What should I do before buying controversial games?
Research their mechanics, watch unedited gameplay, and read mixed reviews — not just positive ones. Understanding expectations reduces disappointment.
✨ Final Thoughts
All ten of these games share one thing: courage. They dare to alienate players rather than please everyone. They stumble, frustrate, and even annoy — yet, in the process, they create memorable experiences.
You might not love all of them, and that’s fine. But try one or two from this list, and you’ll understand what makes gaming such a vibrant art form: the willingness to take risks.
So the next time you hesitate before clicking “Buy,” remember — sometimes the games that look like a mistake are the ones you’ll remember forever.
⚠️ Disclaimer
All mentioned games are the properties of their respective developers and publishers. Gameplay experiences may vary depending on updates and patches. Always verify system requirements before purchase.
#Gaming2025 #ControversialGames #HiddenGems #RiskyBuys #IndieGames #Vampyr #Silksong #BabySteps #SupergiantGames #GameReview
